For Photo Library: CD, DVD, or Hard Drive?
What type of storage should you choose for your photo library? It’s the most important question facing you when you set up your backup routine. This section covers the pros and cons for some digital media that are good for backups. See the table below for a summary and cost comparison.
Note: The storage capacity estimates in this chapter are based on digital photos about 5 MB in size, which is typical for a 5- or 6-megapixel camera. If you have an older digital camera, your photos may be smaller (and you can store more photos in less space). If you have pro equipment that exceeds 6 megapixels, your photos may take up more space.
| Number of 5 MB Photos | Media Cost | Cost per 1,000 photos | |
|---|---|---|---|
| CD-R (50 pack) | 7,000 (per 50 pack) | $10.00 | $1.43 |
| DVD, single-sided (50 pack) | 47,000 (per 50 pack) | $30.00 | $0.64 |
| External drive 60 gigabyte | 12,000 | $150.00 | $12.50 |
| External drive 120 gigabyte | 24,000 | $160.00 | $6.67 |
| External drive 250 gigabyte | 50,000 | $225.00 | $4.50 |
| External drive 500 gigabyte | 100,000 | $375.00 | $3.75 |
1. CDs (CD-R)
A single disc is 700 megabytes and holds about 140 photos. CD-R discs are a better choice than CD-RW discs because they’re cheaper and you can’t accidentally erase your photos once they’re saved on the disc. “RW” stands for “rewriteable,” which is a geeky way of saying you can always change the contents of a CD-RW disc. In contrast, saving photos to a CD-R (”recordable”) disc is a one time only deal (that’s why some people call them “write-once”). Once the photos are on the disc you can’t delete them, which is just what you want with a backup.
Pro: CDs are inexpensive and you can buy them at office supply or computer stores. You can copy your photos to CDs in Windows, so you won’t need any special software.
Con: CDs don’t hold a lot of photos, which means you have to burn more discs and need more room to store them.
2. Single Layer DVDs (DVD-R, DVD+R)
A single layer DVD is 4.7 gigabytes and holds about 940 photos. Use DVDs that can’t be erased after you’ve written to them (that is, don’t use any DVD whose name ends in “RW”). DVDs come in two formats: DVD-R and DVD+R. Use the type that’s compatible with your PC’s DVD drive.
Pro: Write-once DVDs have all the advantages of CDs and then some. They hold almost seven times as many photos as CDs and the overall cost per photo is less than CDs.
Con: Windows Explorer doesn’t have an option for saving files to a DVD, so you need another program like Roxio’s Easy Media Creator (www.roxio.com; $80) or Nero Ultra (www.nero.com; $80).
3. Dual Layer DVDs
If your PC is of a relatively recent vintage you may have a dual-layer DVD burner, which crams data into, you guessed it, two slices of the DVD.
Pro: A dual layer DVD can hold up to 8.5 GB of storage (about 1,700 photos).
Con: You’ll need special dual-layer DVDs, which are the most expensive kind.
4. External Hard Drives
External hard drives, which plug into your PC via a USB or FireWire port, hold anywhere from 40 to 500 gigabytes. A 200 GB drive, which is fairly common, holds about 40,000 photos. Copying your photos to a hard drive is the easiest way to back up your photos.
Pro: External drives work best for several reasons. You can disconnect the drive from your computer to protect your photos. You can use the drive to move photos to another computer. You can keep the drive’s power turned off, which increases its life expectancy.
Con: Hard drives have moving parts and are more fragile than other types of media. A hard drive can fail at any time. A pessimistic life expectancy for hard drives is two to five years. Hard drives are a significant expense, since they cost anywhere from around $100 for an 80 GB model to over $400 for a beefy 500 GB unit. You don’t need the fastest or the biggest hard drive to back up your photos, but you do want one that’s reliable.
Tip: Unlike write-once CDs or DVDs, the files on a hard drive can be erased or changed. To add an extra level of protection to your hard drive’s backup photo files, change the file properties to read only so that the files can’t be erased or written over. In Windows, select your photos and then choose File
Properties. In the Properties box, turn on the Read Only checkbox. You can protect multiple files or entire folders at a time; just make your selection before you open the Properties box.
5. Internal Hard Drives
If your computer has two hard drives, it’s good practice to keep a backup of your photos on each drive. A popular size these days is 200 GB, which holds about 40,000 photos (if you don’t keep anything else on the drive).
Pro: You can simply drag and drop photos to copy them to your second drive, which jibes with the “best backup routine is the one you’ll stick with” maxim. And the photos are equally easy to retrieve.
Con: Anything that happens to your PC can affect anything and everything inside it, so your second drive is in many ways no safer than your first. It’s just a duplicate. For example, if your PC is stolen, you’ve lost both drives. A virus that infects your PC could spread to all internal drives. Also, internal drives are running any time your computer is on, so they get more wear and tear, which means they’re more likely to go kaput.
